New study does not support caffeine as appetite suppressant or weight-loss aid
Caffeine is frequently added to dietary supplements with claims that it suppresses appetite and facilitates weight loss, but a new study published in the Journal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics found that its affect does not last long.
Participants in the study, after drinking a small amount of caffeine, consumer 10 percent less at a breakfast buffet provided by researchers, but as the day went on, the caffeine had not impact on participants’ perceptions of their appetites. Based on these findings, investigators have concluded that caffeine is not effective as an appetite suppressant and weight-loss aid.
Previous research has speculated that caffeine speeds metabolism or affects brain chemicals that suppress appetite. In addition, epidemiological evidence suggests that regular caffeine consumers have a lower body mass index (BMI) than non-consumers. The purpose of our study was to determine whether caffeine can in fact be linked to reduced food intake or suppressed appetite, and if the results vary by BMI, according to Leah M. Panek-Shirley, PhD, lead investigator and faculty at The State University College at Buffalo’s Department Exercise and Nutrition Sciences in New York.
On average, Americans drink eight ounces of coffee per day. Fifty healthy adults aged 18-50 years old visited the investigators' laboratory weekly over a month to participate in the study. Each time, they were asked to drink juice with added caffeine that was either equivalent to consumption of four ounces (1 mg/kg) or eight ounces (3 mg/kg) of coffee, or no coffee as a placebo dose. Thirty minutes later, participants were instructed to eat as much or as little as they wanted of a hearty breakfast buffet. The investigators asked participants to record everything they ate throughout each entire study day and sent them hourly reminder emails, linked to an online survey, to document their intake and appetite at each interval.
The study determined that after drinking the juice with 1 kg/mg of caffeine, participants consumed about 70 fewer calories than they did after drinking juice with 3 mg/kg or no added caffeine. After reviewing what the participants ate for the rest of each study day, they found the small decrease in intake did not persist. Participants compensated for the reduced intake at breakfast later in the day. In addition, there were no differences in reported appetite associated with the caffeine doses. Finally, their individual BMIs had no effect on their food intake or appetite at all three caffeine levels.
This study, by nature of its rigorous design, reinforces the importance of good eating habits and not relying on unsupported weight loss aids or unhealthy practices, according to Carol DeNysschen, PhD, RD, MPH, CDN, FAND, one of the investigators and professor and chair of the Department of Health, Nutrition, and Dietetics at The State University College at Buffalo.
She elaborated on the rigor of the double-blind, randomized, crossover design of the study: the order of the doses was randomized for the 50 participants, both participants and researchers did not know the dose of samples as they were being presented, and all participants received all dose treatments, thereby acting as their own controls to enable comparisons of their individual responses.